Home >Unlabelled > Older Antipsychotics May Work as Well as Newer Ones: Review
Older Antipsychotics May Work as Well as Newer Ones: Review
Posted on Thursday, August 16, 2012 by Health and Wellness News
TUESDAY, Aug. 14 (HealthDay News) -- Newer, more expensive schizophrenia medications are not noticeably better than their older, cheaper counterparts, a new review suggests.
Currently, 75 percent of U.S. adults who are prescribed antipsychotic medications take these second-generation drugs, which were developed largely due to concerns about side effects with their predecessors, experts noted.
First-generation antipsychotics are also called typical antipsychotics. This class of drugs includes chlorpromazine (Thorazine), haloperidol (Haldol), perphenazine (Etrafon, Trilafon) and fluphenazine (Prolixin). Second-generation drugs, known as atypical, antipsychotics include risperidone (Risperdal), aripiprazole (Abilify), olanzapine (Zyprexa), quetiapine Fumarate (Seroquel) and ziprasidone (Geodon). There is a major cost difference between the two classes of drugs: For example, a month's supply of olanzapine can cost $546, while a month's supply of haloperidol ranges from $18 to $27, according to Consumer Reports.
But are these newer drugs really more effective or less risky? Researchers at the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality reviewed 114 studies involving 22 comparisons between the two classes of drugs to answer these questions. Their review appears in the Aug. 14 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine.
The review found that the second-generation antipsychotics are not much better than the earlier incarnations at treating positive symptoms associated with schizophrenia. "Positive symptoms" is the umbrella term for symptoms of psychosis such as delusions and hallucinations. By contrast, negative symptoms reflect a decrease or loss of normal function including expression or speech.
Two second-generation drugs, olanzapine and risperidone, did seem to be more effective at treating negative symptoms when compared with the older haloperidol, the investigators said.
There was insufficient evidence to compare risk profiles between the two classes of drugs, the researchers said. Long-term risks of antipsychotics may include diabetes, major metabolic syndrome and a neurological disorder that causes involuntary, repetitive movements (tardive dyskinesia). Metabolic syndrome refers to a cluster of risk factors that increase risk for diabetes and heart disease.
"The typical antipsychotics that have been around for a long time are just as good at treating schizophrenia symptoms as the newer ones," said Dr. Dolores Malaspina, director of the Institute for Social and Psychiatric Initiatives at NYU Langone Medical Center in New York City. In the future, doctors may adopt a personalized medicine approach to better pair treatments with individual symptoms and disease manifestations, she suggested.
Until then, "my first choice would be to try one of the medications that have a longer track record, and then move on if need be," Malaspina said, adding that the main differences between the first- and second-generation medications are side effects.
Commenting on the review, Dr. David Straker, an adjunct assistant clinical professor of psychiatry at Columbia University Medical Center in New York City, said: "The newer drugs seem to be more effective with negative symptoms and, as such, they help with concentration and focus, but they cost a lot more and may have more metabolic side effects. It comes down to weighing the risks versus the benefit in each individual patient."
And, according to Dr. Roberto Estrada, a psychiatrist at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City, the review raises an important issue that psychiatrists face in treating people with schizophrenia.
"The limitations of first-generation antipsychotics were well known prior to the introduction of second-generation antipsychotics, but now the metabolic issues and expense associated with using second-generation antipsychotics has created further challenges in the treatment of schizophrenia," Estrada said.
The new review "is unable to draw clear conclusions about differences between the two in the treatment of schizophrenia," Estrada explained. "However, in clinical practice using the second-generation drugs, we see comparable symptom management with little acute adverse effects, but different and equally long-term adverse effects."
Via: Older Antipsychotics May Work as Well as Newer Ones: Review
Popular Posts
-
Deciding not to step out into the Black Friday foray, Julianne Hough and Ryan Seacrest opted for a post-Thanksigivng vacation in...
-
Rodrigo Cid Cynthia Nixon has an Emmy and a Tony, and she also has flawless skin. But that hasn't always been the case. After strugg...
-
FRIDAY, June 8 (HealthDay News) -- The public's common image of a Botox patient is a middle-aged woman hoping to look more youthful th...
-
TUESDAY, July 17 (HealthDay News) -- Restrictions on young people's use of indoor tanning have been introduced by several countries in...
-
Featured wedding by Wedding 64, My Simply Perfect Weddings ...
-
THURSDAY, July 5 (HealthDay News) -- As many as one in five Americans has to deal each day with symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome, a di...
-
Wedding dresses that give you two looks for the price of one...
-
QUILL/TAXI/GETTY IMAGES The first new weight-loss drug in 13 years was approved Wednesday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Th...
-
WEDNESDAY, July 25 (HealthDay News) -- Rates of esophageal cancer have surged due to a lack of awareness about what causes the disease and...
-
MONDAY, July 16 (HealthDay News) -- The new blood-thinning drug Brilinta should be considered along with older drugs to treat patients wit...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(1044)
-
▼
August
(125)
- Write a Fashion Police Caption for Ali Larter
- Rebecca Taylor, Scotch & Soda, and Minnie Mouse St...
- John Galliano stripped of Legion of Honour followi...
- 10 Incredibly Gorgeous Transforming Wedding Dresse...
- Best Bet: Dieppa Restrepo Cali Oxfords
- Murad Anti-Aging Product Spotlight: Intensive Wrin...
- Russell Brand and Geri Halliwell are dating. No ho...
- Acquired Taste Learn To Love Cilantro
- FDA Approves New Once-a-Day HIV Pill
- Video: Doctor Who's Matt Smith, Karen Gillan and A...
- Long Hairstyles
- The Boyfriend Stylist Strikes Again! Kanye West Gi...
- Celebrity Beauty How To Video: The Off-Duty Top Kn...
- Valentinos State of Grace
- For the Multi-Taskers, Clarins Launches New Cream
- The Best Over 40 Foundation and How to Get Full Lips
- Jessica Hart Is the Face (and Body) of Mambo Godde...
- Sophia Bush Talks Politics On Twitter
- Overloaded Backpacks Can Injure Kids: Experts
- Sleep Boosts Memory for Parkinson's Patients, Stud...
- Overweight Kids More Prone to Gallstones: Study
- Missing Follow-Up Colonoscopies Could Raise Colon ...
- Study of Brain-Injured Man Sheds Light on Self-Awa...
- Doctors Who 'Self-Refer' to Radiation Clinics Add ...
- Close Relative's Early Death May Raise Your Heart ...
- Could Food Flavors Act Like Mood-Stabilizing Drugs?
- The Knowledge: how to do luxe-casual dressing
- Tying the Knot Ups Women's Drinking Rate, Lowers M...
- Health, Social Life Improve After Weight-Loss Surg...
- College Students Don't Respect Peers Who 'Hook Up'...
- ADHD May Raise Girls' Risk for Suicide as Young Ad...
- Chemicals From Soaps, Cleansers Found in Minnesot...
- Healthy-Looking Pigs at State Fair Found to Have S...
- Solving the Medical Mystery of Cold Feet
- Dallas Launches Insecticide Spraying Against West ...
- Global Tobacco Use Remains High, Survey Finds
- Sharp as a Tack at 90: Here's Why
- Experimental Drug May Cut Severe Asthma Attacks: S...
- Older Americans Living Longer, But Becoming More O...
- Blacks More Prone to Hypertension After Certain St...
- 'Yo-Yo' Dieting Won't Harm Long-Term Weight Loss E...
- Male Birth Control Drug Shows Promise in Mice
- Test All Baby Boomers For Hepatitis C: CDC
- North Texas Cities to Start West Nile Spraying Thu...
- Sleep Apnea Affects Many Women, Too
- New Pill Appears Effective, Safe for Ulcerative Co...
- PSA Test's Overall Benefit Still Unclear: Study
- Man's Best Friend Points the Way in Genetic Research
- New Drug Appears to Extend Survival in Advanced Pr...
- Could Chocolate's Antioxidants Boost Brain Function?
- Not Enough Data to Advise Routine Hearing Screens ...
- Drug May Aid People With Advanced Thyroid Cancer
- Dallas, Fort Worth Brace for West Nile Spraying
- Genetic Studies Give Clues to Tourette Syndrome, OCD
- Older Antipsychotics May Work as Well as Newer One...
- Pain Reported by Nearly Half With Type 2 Diabetes
- Newer Bone Drug Better for Advanced Breast Cancer ...
- Couples Therapy May Help Combat PTSD
- Physical, Mental Toll of Japanese Nuke Plant Meltd...
- A Few Hours of Weekly Exercise May Help Women's Bones
- Routine Screening Won't Cut Rates of Domestic Viol...
- Poor Economy Tied to Rise in Suicides, British Stu...
- Egg Yolks Almost as Bad for Arteries as Smoking: S...
- New 'Brain-Cleaning' System Discovered in Mice
- Three Kids Dead From Codeine After Surgery: FDA
- Some Families May Have Natural Protection Against ...
- Your Blood Type May Boost Your Heart Risk, Study F...
- Daily Aspirin May Cut Cancer Deaths, Another Study...
- Dyslexia May Be Caused by Signal Processing Proble...
- 'Greening' Vacant Lots May Boost Safety
- The 'Nocebo' Effect: If You Think You'll Get Sick,...
- Migraines Not Linked to Decline in Thinking Skills
- Workers With Disabilities More Prone to Injuries: ...
- FDA Gives Nod to First Drug for Diabetic Eye Disease
- Dental Woes Abound for Developmentally Disabled: S...
- 'Exergames' Can Help Inactive Folks Get Moving: Study
- Advice From a Cancer Veteran: Do What's Best for You
- Screening Debate Typifies Prostate Cancer Uncertai...
- High-Risk Heterosexuals Should Take HIV Prevention...
- Sharp Spike Seen in Swine Flu Cases: CDC
- Male Diners Tip Better When Waitress Wears Red: Study
- Calcium, Vitamin D Supplements May Pose Risks for ...
- Statins' Heart Benefits Outweigh Diabetes Risk: Study
- Electrical Brain Stimulation Curbs Epileptic Seizu...
- Birds' Songs Reflect Changing Weather Patterns: Study
- When Partner Has Breast Cancer, Men Find Their Own...
- Humira Might Help Kids With Tough-to-Treat Crohn's...
- Stressed-Out Men May Prefer Heavier Women
- Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients May Have Higher Risk...
- Two Languages Better Than One for Kids' Brains: Study
- Reductions in U.S. Teen Smoking Stalled: CDC
- Workers Counseled on Back Pain Return to Job Sooner
- Balance, Strength Training Reduce Falls for Elderl...
- Study Compares Safety of 'Biologic' Meds for Rheum...
- Underinsured Heart Disease Patients Die Sooner, St...
- Fainting Might Run in Families, Twin Study Finds
- 7-Day Stuttering Therapy May Get Results, Study Says
- Patients Often Kept in Dark About 'Off-Label' Drug...
- New Pill Might Relieve Severe Rheumatoid Arthritis
- Too Much Travel May Be Tough on Olympians
-
▼
August
(125)
Fishing Tips And Techniques For Beginners
FEMININE INFINITY TATTOO DESIGNS
CUTE DORM ROOM IDEAS
ABC Party Ideas For Girls
Greenpois0n Jailbreak
What Is Best Treadmill
HOW TO GAIN WEIGHT FOR WOMEN
Blogroll
- Rocky Mountain Road Bikes
- What Is Sterling Silver Plated
- Black Gold Dogs Food
- Dining Rooms Paint Colors
- Parents Choices Diapers
- Best K Cups Coffees
- Arts And Crafts For Toddlers
- Healthy Skin Makeup Reviews
- Refurbished Androids Phones
- Techno Gadgets For Kids
- Weddings Makeup Looks
- Womens Fashions Boots
- SSD vs HDD
- Beyonce
- Bluray Disc
- Laptop Bag
- Kokowaah Torrent
- Best Seller Baby Furniture
- Golf Instruction Tips Free
- Camping Tips And Tricks For Beginners
- Best Sports Car In The World
- Smallyard Landscaping Ideas
- Small Backyard Landscaping Ideas
- Hairstyles For Medium Length Hair
- What Is Best Treadmill
- How To Gain Weight For Women
- Technology Green Energy
- Fishing Tips And Techniques For Beginners
- Feminine Infinity Tattoo Designs
- Greenpoisons
- Coal Trading
- Boss Tambang
- Lactoses Intolerance
- Fashion And Beauty Trends
- How To Grow Facial Hair Faster
- Samsung News
- Coal Mining And Geology
- Childs Craft
- Best iPads Apps
- iPhone iPad iPod
- Gtrend
- iPhone 4G
- Gadgetz News
- Facial Hair
- Constant Diarrhea
- Grosir Baju Muslim
- Unlock iPhone Store
- Greenpois0n Jailbreak
- Cute Dorm Room Ideas
- ABC Party Ideas For Girls