Home >Unlabelled > Organic Foods Not Healthier or More Nutritious, Study Says
Organic Foods Not Healthier or More Nutritious, Study Says
Posted on Tuesday, September 4, 2012 by Health and Wellness News
MONDAY, Sept. 3 (HealthDay News) -- Organic foods are almost invariably more expensive than their conventionally produced counterparts but they aren't necessarily healthier or more nutritious, new research suggests.
Scientists found no consistent differences in vitamin content between organic and conventional foods and few significant differences in health benefits. They did note, however, that organic produce is 30 percent less likely to be contaminated with pesticides than conventional fruits and vegetables -- though the pesticide levels of all foods fell within allowable limits -- and that organic chicken and pork appeared to lessen exposure to antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
"I think different people will make different decisions based on our findings," said study author Dr. Crystal Smith-Spangler, an instructor at Stanford University School of Medicine and a physician-investigator at the VA Palo Alto Health Care System, in California. "We thought we'd find more significant differences, but there are many reasons why someone might consume organic foods. Health is one, but they may be concerned about the environment, animal welfare practices or taste, and we weren't evaluating that."
The study is published Sept. 4 in the Annals of Internal Medicine.
Smith-Spangler and her colleagues analyzed 237 previous studies, including 17 involving human consumption of organic vs. conventional diets and 223 comparing either the nutrient levels or the bacterial, fungal or pesticide contamination of products such as fruits, vegetables, grains, meats, milk, poultry and eggs produced organically and conventionally.
Organic foods, often twice as costly as their conventional counterparts, have become big business in the United States in recent years, with estimated sales skyrocketing from $3.6 billion to $26.7 billion between 1997 and 2010, according to study background information.
Organic products are generally grown without synthetic pesticides, fertilizers, irradiation or chemical food additives and without routine use of antibiotics or growth hormones. Organic livestock are offered freedom of movement and access to the outdoors and are fed pesticide- and animal byproduct-free organic feed.
Only one nutrient, phosphorous, was found to be significantly more abundant in organic produce, but researchers felt this had little clinical significance since few people are deficient in phosphorous. Also, no difference in protein or fat content was observed between organic and conventional milk, though limited previous studies did suggest organic milk contains markedly higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids, which may lower the risk of conditions such as heart disease, cancer and arthritis.
Smith-Spangler said she and her team were inspired to undertake the research to find answers for themselves, their families and their patients about the potential merits of organic foods. But, "we didn't find strong evidence that organic food was significantly more nutritious or healthier," she said, "and similar levels of both types are contaminated with bacteria" such as E. coli, which can be deadly.
"We can't exclude the idea that some organic practices may increase nutrient levels . . . or increase or decrease bacteria," she said. "But at the market you don't often get to look at the organic practices used. Many studies mention that other factors can influence nutrient content, such as ripeness, season and storage practices."
Charles Benbrook is chief science consultant at the Organic Center in Enterprise, Ore., which says it conducts "credible, evidence-based science on the health and environmental benefits of organic food and farming." He praised the study authors' "ambitious undertaking" but said the study underestimated the impact of organic livestock farming on reducing antibiotic resistance and missed analyzing research attributing important health benefits from organic produce on prenatal development.
"We need to recognize that finding strong evidence of clinically significant health benefits for eating organic food is a tall order," Benbrook said. "But I don't think their study rules out some of the more subtle benefits of consuming organic foods that are more in the nature of promoting healthy pregnancies and preventing disease."
"To practitioners [like the researchers], a clinically significant outcome and improvement relies on a much more profound change in the health and biology of a person than what most literature speaks to," he added, "which is that people who make decent dietary choices but also buy high-quality organic food . . . improve the odds that they stay healthy."
Via: Organic Foods Not Healthier or More Nutritious, Study Says
Popular Posts
-
Deciding not to step out into the Black Friday foray, Julianne Hough and Ryan Seacrest opted for a post-Thanksigivng vacation in...
-
Rodrigo Cid Cynthia Nixon has an Emmy and a Tony, and she also has flawless skin. But that hasn't always been the case. After strugg...
-
FRIDAY, June 8 (HealthDay News) -- The public's common image of a Botox patient is a middle-aged woman hoping to look more youthful th...
-
TUESDAY, July 17 (HealthDay News) -- Restrictions on young people's use of indoor tanning have been introduced by several countries in...
-
Featured wedding by Wedding 64, My Simply Perfect Weddings ...
-
THURSDAY, July 5 (HealthDay News) -- As many as one in five Americans has to deal each day with symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome, a di...
-
Wedding dresses that give you two looks for the price of one...
-
QUILL/TAXI/GETTY IMAGES The first new weight-loss drug in 13 years was approved Wednesday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Th...
-
WEDNESDAY, July 25 (HealthDay News) -- Rates of esophageal cancer have surged due to a lack of awareness about what causes the disease and...
-
MONDAY, July 16 (HealthDay News) -- The new blood-thinning drug Brilinta should be considered along with older drugs to treat patients wit...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(1044)
-
▼
September
(72)
- New Melanoma Treatment Might Delay Cancer Progression
- Exercise Programs for Kids Seem to Have Little Imp...
- What Anna Wintour and Kristen Stewart Talked About...
- West Nile Cases Rise by 400 Since Last Week: CDC
- See a Preview of SJP's Glee Episode Because What E...
- Skin Care Tips for Lovers of Hot Yoga (Bikram)
- Top Beauty Product Winners at 2009 CEW Beauty Awards
- Sarah Ann Macklin British GQ October 2012 Feature
- Giuliana Rancic's 2012 Emmy Look: All the Details!
- New Spring 2013 Shows: Anthony Vaccarello, Cdric C...
- Best Shoes for a Formal Dress
- Ryan Gosling & Rooney Mara Get Intimate on the Lon...
- Working Out Cuts Women's Appetite, Study Finds
- Ellie Goulding reveals video for new song
- 7 Boozy Gifts for Libation-Lovin Bridesmaids
- Make Sweet And Spicy Cherry Salsa
- Gene Study Yields New Clues to Breast Cancer
- Blumarine Spring 2013 Runway Review
- Bride's Wedding Jitters May Forecast Stormy Marriage
- Poor Sleep May Make High Blood Pressure Worse
- Survival After General Anesthesia Vastly Improved:...
- Recharge Your Relationship in One Weekend
- Can Acne Affect You Emotionally?
- Watch Alex Reids emotional appeal to Chantelle Hou...
- Happy Hour Bloody Maria
- Most Forehead Lift Patients Recommend Procedure: S...
- Heart Deaths Rise With Extreme Temperatures, Study...
- Christina Aguilera's teaser video for new single Y...
- Take Our Fashion Week IQ Quiz And Find Out If You'...
- Millie Mackintosh Reveals Her New Eyelash Line! So...
- Meadham Kirchhoffs Gilded Disillusion
- Reduce, Reuse and Recycle: Green Eyes
- Over 40? Heres How to Wear Falls Military Trend
- Olivia Wilde & Jason Sudeikis Cozy West Village St...
- How Jessica Simpson Is Losing the Baby Weight
- Stale 3-Day-Old Hamburger Flattered to Be Getting ...
- Downton Abbey is back tonight! Heres what to expec...
- Back to School Updos
- Fashion Question: How Old Should Your Clothes Be B...
- Backstage at London Fashion Week: What's In Meliss...
- Obesity Hits Rural Areas Harder Than Cities
- Nicki Minaj and Keith Urban Officially Join "Ameri...
- Skin Doctor Offers Tips to Reduce Acne
- Quitting Drinking May Help Alcoholics' Bone Loss
- Perfect Shoes For Mother Of The Bride
- September Starts Stress Season: Tips to Ease Up an...
- Prince William & Kate Middleton's Kuala Lumpur Mos...
- This weeks Celebrity Juice should be called Celebr...
- London Fashion Week spring/summer 2013 latest
- Whimsical Rainbows, Chevron & Stripes, and Cacti W...
- Grill Octopus (Yes, Octopus!)
- Lets coo over pictures of Pink and baby Willow in ...
- Scientists Spot 5 Genes That Help Shape Faces
- New Device May Reduce Repeat Breast Cancer Surgeries
- Trend Alert - Blunt Bangs and Windswept Hair
- Water or Sports Drink?
- New Spring 2013 Shows: Marc Jacobs, Reem Acra, and...
- Chrystal Copland Kicks Off Fashion Month by Landin...
- Lip, Not Hip Plumping, With New Gloss
- Emma Watson Was Awesome in Erdem at The Perks of B...
- Theyskens Theory: Risqu and Roll
- Backstage At New York Fashion Week: What's In Karl...
- LOL! Mindy Kaling Pretends to Attend New York Fash...
- Duchess of Cambridge wears kimono style Jenny Pack...
- Experts Offer Tips to Help Keep Fall Sports Injury...
- The 4 Best Exercises for a Healthy Heart
- The Plague: It's Still With Us
- Laundry Detergent Packs Pose Poisoning Threat to T...
- Longer Resuscitation After Cardiac Arrest May Be W...
- Organic Foods Not Healthier or More Nutritious, St...
- Marathons Safe for Aging Boomers, Study Finds
- Women's Brains React Differently Than Men's to Alc...
-
▼
September
(72)
Fishing Tips And Techniques For Beginners
FEMININE INFINITY TATTOO DESIGNS
CUTE DORM ROOM IDEAS
ABC Party Ideas For Girls
Greenpois0n Jailbreak
What Is Best Treadmill
HOW TO GAIN WEIGHT FOR WOMEN
Blogroll
- Rocky Mountain Road Bikes
- What Is Sterling Silver Plated
- Black Gold Dogs Food
- Dining Rooms Paint Colors
- Parents Choices Diapers
- Best K Cups Coffees
- Arts And Crafts For Toddlers
- Healthy Skin Makeup Reviews
- Refurbished Androids Phones
- Techno Gadgets For Kids
- Weddings Makeup Looks
- Womens Fashions Boots
- SSD vs HDD
- Beyonce
- Bluray Disc
- Laptop Bag
- Kokowaah Torrent
- Best Seller Baby Furniture
- Golf Instruction Tips Free
- Camping Tips And Tricks For Beginners
- Best Sports Car In The World
- Smallyard Landscaping Ideas
- Small Backyard Landscaping Ideas
- Hairstyles For Medium Length Hair
- What Is Best Treadmill
- How To Gain Weight For Women
- Technology Green Energy
- Fishing Tips And Techniques For Beginners
- Feminine Infinity Tattoo Designs
- Greenpoisons
- Coal Trading
- Boss Tambang
- Lactoses Intolerance
- Fashion And Beauty Trends
- How To Grow Facial Hair Faster
- Samsung News
- Coal Mining And Geology
- Childs Craft
- Best iPads Apps
- iPhone iPad iPod
- Gtrend
- iPhone 4G
- Gadgetz News
- Facial Hair
- Constant Diarrhea
- Grosir Baju Muslim
- Unlock iPhone Store
- Greenpois0n Jailbreak
- Cute Dorm Room Ideas
- ABC Party Ideas For Girls